@Jim Eshelman said
"
@moonchilde said
"So, to sum up, whatever happens to one is factual "True Will", regardless of ANY circumstances.
Is this an accurate assessment?"
No, I wouldn't say it is at all.
Although... just maybe... you mean something different from your words than I see in them."
Here is a survey of some quote on the board.
I am not asking you to take responsibility for anyone's comments, but to express your understanding of how Thelema supports the viewpoint.
So we start with a clean strawman to work with, I would suggest that getting caught for drug posession has equal Choice and Will content as getting hit by a car walking across the street or perhaps getting a cold.
If anyone believes this is not the case, please explain.
Given that, some quotes:
*If you are imprisoned (on parole), this suggests you violated the Law of Will to get yourself to that point and you will have to endure its consequences until you learn better.
*
Among the many, many implications of all of this is that you, as an individual, are also inseparable from the society
Did you will yourself to prison? In a way, you did (and of course, in a way, you didn't). In any case, by whatever means, you did not do what is called "True Will" unless going to prison is what you want to call your True Will.
"
"Being born in Jim Crow's America, for example, would not imply complicity and subservience to racial segregation."
It MIGHT imply either of those. It may also imply a need to punish oneself, the need for a lesson in humility, a setup for political activism, a need to be where other suffering and suppressed people need support, a motivation to leave the area, a positioning of oneself to be a witness to that phase of history, or countless other things. In any case, it isn't inconsequential and isn't without choice."
You are not a victim, you are a perpetrator who got caught.
"You broke the law, you got caught, there are consequences" probably sounds like a defense of the law. (At least, it probably sounds that way to somebody who eventually will read this <g>.) It isn't. It's just stating facts, circumstances in which you exist.
*So... like I've mentioned before, these inconveniences on your will that currently exist may in fact (actually, I'm quite sure they do) point in the direction of your True Will. *
The thing for YOU to get in all of this is that you have voluntarily entered into a system which has these circumstances.
Perhaps you could see where I might infer that?
Please clear up my confusion, thanks.