The HGA and Christian god
-
"I was just curious as to how those similarities in the relationship between the devotee and the HGA (or god in the christian sense) are evidence that they are the same?"
How are similarities evidence that they are the same?
I think I know what you're heading for, but to be sure, do you mind clarifying the question? Similarity is evidence of sameness.
-
@Aegis55 said
"do you mind clarifying the question?"
No problem, I'm communication challenged sometimes. Just see any thread where Redd Fezz and I talk in circles for 10+ posts..
My question is: how can you say that the thelemic concept of K&C with the HGA is the same as the protestant idea of a personal relationship with God, based solely on similarities in the characteristics of the relationships?
The idea I originally put forth was that, christians often use "god told me to do X,Y,Z" because they were too chicken to own up to wanting to do something. I asked if it were possible that Thelemites might be doing something similar with their supposed relationship with the HGA. Thus, abusing the concept. I understand where you're coming from about not having the HGA tell others what to do, but I was referring to using it as justification for the individuals decisions they didn't want to own up to.
My statements are pretty convoluted, so let me give you an example. A guy is dating a girl. He decides he doesn't want to date her anymore. Since they're both Christians, he simply says that "God is telling me that I shouldn't be with you anymore." Basically because he's too spineless to own up to his own feelings, and has to hide behind his "god," using this external entity as an excuse.
However, Frater Potater confirmed my thoughts on the position of the HGA, it makes this situation much more honest for the Thelemite since the HGA is the True Self, and therefore, the individual is simply following their True Will.
@Aegis55 said
"Similarity is evidence of sameness."
I would have to respectfully disagree. Either that, or draw a distinction between same and sameness. You see, there are plenty of situations where two things can have similarities and not actually be the same thing, but still have "sameness."
Really appreciate you taking the time to respond, Aegis55.
-ANEA
"When the student is ready, the teacher will appear." -
@Idiosyncratic said
"
@Aegis55 said
"I picture him in the cockpit of a very old time/consciousness machine trying to find the proper bearings to land the big damned old thing in the current Aeon without destroying absolutely everything with it, and thus defeating the point of their role in preservation. "Do you think it's true what they say about the Vatican holding the largest occult book collection in the world? I suspect that there are very few people in the WMT that would turn down an opportunity to browse the Vatican Library.
"I would personally hand the pope my left nut for unrestricted, lifetime access to the vaults and their resources(translators, etc). Lol
-
Here is what I said:
"Yes, in my experience of Protestant Christianity, you might say that they preach the ideal of "a personal relationship with God" that my own journey has led me to understand as being perfected and fulfilled in the occultist's conception of Knowledge and Conversation of the HGA. "
I'm saying the aspiration is the same. The expectations, experiences, and explanations change along the journey.
-
"Do you think it's true what they say about the Vatican holding the largest occult book collection in the world?"
I astral projected to the vatican library when i was a young boy but an angel with a flaming sword blocked my path.
-
When I actually busy myself with the Work, then philosophy and vocabulary fall away and become irrelevant. As a child (raised a Protestant Xian), I thought in terms of "inviting Jesus into my heart" and "seeking God's purpose for my life". As a Thelemite, I think in terms of "invoking the HGA" and "seeking my True Will." But my interior experience and my intimate relationship with the Cosmic Whatnot are "ever the same", probably unique to myself, and beyond words and symbols. Likewise, I may think that I'm meditating or praying or invoking or contemplating, but increasingly it seems to me that there is only one practice.
So what does it mean that I call myself a Thelemite and abhor Xianity? Perhaps no more than that I like kale and can't abide asparagus.
"Yea! deem not of change: ye shall be as ye are & not other." I've had Xian phases, Buddhist phases, Thelemic phases, and others. But in my inmost self, I am none of these, and my relation to this world may grow deeper but not other.
-
@gmugmble said
"...I like kale and can't abide asparagus. "
That's just wrong!
Admit it, Kale is disgusting while Asparagus rocks!Love and Will
-
@RobertAllen said
"
@gmugmble said
"...I like kale and can't abide asparagus. "That's just wrong!
Admit it, Kale is disgusting while Asparagus rocks!Love and Will"
The fool eateth kale and understandeth it not. Let him come through the first ordeal & it will be to him ... oh, never mind. -
I think we need to clarify the sect of Christinaity. However, Christianity tends to hold to the idea of a transcendent God that is separate from humanity, wherein the HGA is a part of who we are.
Quite frankly, there are so many qualities to the Christian idea of God that it would be almost impossible to classify "Him" within a Qabbalistic or Thelemic context. It really depends on what aspect you are referring to.
There are some aspects that can be found in every Sephirah of the Tree of Life- insofar as I have studied.I have given a bit of reflection to "Love is the Law, Love under Will" and how that applies to the Catholic Dogma, as I myself used to be Catholic. I feel that the idea of the HGA, within the Catholic religion has almost a 1:1 correspondence with the exception that the HGA in the Thelemic context is a part of ourself, wherein in the Catholic faith, it visualized as an external entity. In either path, it is our connection to divine powers. I do, however, find tremendous correlation with the concept of "Love", as is written in the Law, and the concept of the Holy Spirit.
-
@HWNH said
"I feel that the idea of the HGA, within the Catholic religion has almost a 1:1 correspondence with the exception that the HGA in the Thelemic context is a part of ourself, wherein in the Catholic faith, it visualized as an external entity."
Yes, I was saying the same thing from a Protestant perspective. It shares the same exception as well.
-
Here is an article that talks a little about this subject. At the end, there is a link to a video clip by Lon Duquette where he mentions the similarity in the goal of every ecstatic mystic that every walked the face of the earth. Another aspect of the video clip that is a little bit off the subject, never the less, very interesting, is that, keep in mind, when you watch the video clip, the prince also represents the Beast 666 (the number for the sphere of Tiphareth is 666) and see how he is consorting with Babalon, the feminine aspect, up and down the tree. When she rises back up the tree to the Throne of Binah, this is the aspect of her that we are most familiar with, where she is riding atop the Beast with seven heads. The seven heads are the seven lower sephiroth of the tree. - unusmundus-melie.blogspot.com/2011/05/writing-by-me-thelema-morality-and.html
Also, this article about Baphomet, Alchemy and The Temple of Solomon contains some good info on what kinds of similarities there are. - unusmundus-melie.blogspot.com/2009/09/writing-by-me-baphomet-alchemcy-temple.html
-
[emphasis mine]
@Bereshith said
"I used to be very angry with the Pope. I've had just a few years to study these things, and they've had centuries. But these days,*** I picture him in the cockpit of a very old time/consciousness machine trying to find the proper bearings to land the big damned old thing in the current Aeon without destroying absolutely everything with it***, and thus defeating the point of their role in preservation. Conundrum. That's what I think about Rome these days - if they are indeed following along in the procession of the Aeons as they have certainly had the opportunity to be."
I was rather struck by some wording in Pope Benedict's resignation announcement [emphasis mine]:
@Pope Benedic said
"However, in today's world, subject to so many rapid changes and shaken by questions of deep relevance for the life of faith, ***in order to govern the bark of Saint Peter ***and proclaim the Gospel, both strength of mind and body are necessary, strength which in the last few months, has deteriorated in me to the extent that I have had to recognize my incapacity to adequately fulfill the ministry entrusted to me. "
"...in order to govern the bark of Saint Peter..." Sometimes their choice of words makes me wonder how much they understand. Perhaps it's a vain hope. I don't know.
-
Bereshith;
Sometimes your choice of words makes me wonder how much you understand, or refuse to understand. Granted, the Roman Catholic Church is an Old Aeon vessel - but it was a righted vessel at one time or another. Don't throw the baby out with the baptism. -
93,
""...in order to govern the bark of Saint Peter..." Sometimes their choice of words makes me wonder how much they understand. Perhaps it's a vain hope. I don't know."
I've always held the belief that the pope has all the 'old' books that they seized during the witch trials. I also believe them to be intelligent people who have probably learnt classical mythology at some point and also will be well aware of Thelema and other religions, even if they view it as a competition of faith. They must know the origins of their own religion lies in a various gluing together of pagan myths.
I also liked his emphasis on strength, relating to Geburah and back to Ra Hoor Khuit. But maybe that's just a coincidence.
Its a shame the smiling pope (Pope John Paul I) was assassinated, he had some ideas which would have made me respect Catholicism more.
Anyway, thanks for sharing.
93's.
-
-
Was right what the church did in the past, but it´s not right now, when they are still the same rancid bullshit? I don´t get that.
-
@Takamba said
"Bereshith;
Sometimes your choice of words makes me wonder how much you understand, or refuse to understand. Granted, the Roman Catholic Church is an Old Aeon vessel - but it was a righted vessel at one time or another. Don't throw the baby out with the baptism."Hm. I'm not sure of the misunderstanding. It's probably my fault though. And the original post is from two years ago...
I would love nothing more than for the Catholic Church, guided by those piloting Saint Peter's ship of consciousness, to find a way to understand "Jesus" as the initial "stand-in" name for the HGA, much like Thelemic aspirants are encouraged intially to use "Aiwass."
I know the name "Jesus" has served that purpose for me, but I had to jump ship, and I had a really hard swim.
Man, wouldn't it be incredible for them to land that big old ship in the current Aeon in a way that provided congruence for its members making the transition from one Aeon to the other?
"He's got....high hopes..."
-
Step 1: Retreat from the position that "Evil is the 'privation of Good'" (ala Augustine) and go with something more along the lines of "Evil is the result of the ignorance that precedes learning."
Step 2: Allow for many past references to "man" or "humanity" to be refering to the level of human personality while acknowledging that human beings are capable of experiencing more than that one level of themselves along the inner spectrum existing from the human personality to the Divine. Orthodox Christianity has long worked with the concept of "apotheosis," so this isn't a completely impossible stretch.
With those two seeds, much could grow.
Like I said... "high hopes..."
-
@Smokey Monking said
"Was right what the church did in the past, but it´s not right now, when they are still the same rancid bullshit? I don´t get that."
You fail to separate one conclusion from the other. In the Old Aeon, Old Aeon things worked. To say you agree that something was once right is not to say that you agree that that something is always right. It is right to add cream to tea if you enjoy that sort of thing, but not if the tea is still boiling (as the cream will curdle and taste sour).
Not all things of the Old Aeon are black, only those that need to be purged (black and white thinking, for instance).